Opportunities and Challenges in Japanese Cross-Border M&A Amid Economic Recovery

Current Landscape

The Japanese cross-border M&A landscape in 2024 is characterized by a resurgence of activity driven by macroeconomic factors, particularly the persistent weakness of the yen. After a period of relative stagnation, the market has shown signs of robust growth, with both inbound and outbound transactions gaining momentum. In 2023, Japan experienced significant growth in corporate M&A deal value, amassing a total of $123 billion, a 23% increase from the previous year. This upward trend has continued into 2024, with several high-profile deals setting the tone, such as Nippon Steel’s proposed $15 billion acquisition of United States Steel in December 2023. The weak yen has created a dual dynamic: it has made Japanese companies more attractive to foreign buyers, boosting inbound M&A interest, while also increasing the cost for Japanese firms pursuing acquisitions abroad. Despite this, outbound M&A activity from Japan has shown resilience, contrasting with the Asia Pacific region’s 25% decline in deal values. Japanese companies are increasingly looking overseas for growth opportunities, continuing the momentum from 2023.

The regulatory environment has evolved, notably influenced by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry’s (METI) issuance of Takeover Guidelines in August 2023. These guidelines have reshaped Japan’s M&A landscape by enhancing disclosure requirements, mandating detailed post-acquisition plans, enforcing stricter rules on defensive measures, and encouraging independent committee evaluations of takeover bids. Emphasizing shareholder rights and market transparency, these changes have increased successful offers and competing bids in late 2023 and early 2024. Financing trends have also shifted, with cash reserves and private debt becoming preferred methods for M&A transactions in 2024, moving away from traditional bank loans and public debt offerings.

Economic Factors

Japan’s economic landscape has undergone significant changes as the country emerges from decades-long deflation. This shift, coupled with a weakened yen, has profound implications for M&A activities.

Positive

Increased Attractiveness for Foreign Buyers: The weakened yen has made Japanese companies more affordable for foreign investors. This currency depreciation effectively lowers the acquisition cost for foreign buyers, making Japanese firms attractive targets. The yen’s depreciation has led to a surge in inbound M&A interest, particularly from North America and European investors who are looking to capitalize on the favorable exchange rates and the relatively low valuations of Japanese companies.

Boost to Export-Driven Firms: The weakened yen has also benefited Japanese export-driven companies by making their products more competitive in the global market. This increased competitiveness can enhance the financial performance of these companies, making them more attractive targets. Sectors such as automotive, electronics, and machinery have seen a significant uptick in foreign interest due to their improved export performance.

Negative

Increased Cost of Outbound M&A: While the weakened yen has made Japanese companies cheaper for foreign buyers, it has simultaneously increased the cost for Japanese firms looking to make acquisitions abroad. The higher cost of foreign assets, when converted back to yen, poses a significant challenge for Japanese companies pursuing outbound M&A. This has led to a more cautious approach among Japanese firms, with some delaying or scaling back their international expansion plans. The number of outbound M&A deals has decreased as companies reassess their strategies considering the higher costs.

Inflationary Pressures and Economic Uncertainty: The return of inflation in Japan, while a sign of economic recovery, has introduced new challenges. Rising costs of commodities and wages can squeeze profit margins, making it more difficult for companies to justify large-scale acquisitions. Inflationary pressures have led to increased scrutiny of potential deals, with companies more focused on cost synergies and operational efficiencies to offset rising expenses. Sectors with high input costs, such as manufacturing and construction, are particularly affected by these inflationary pressures.

Historical Impact

1. Late 1980s Inflationary Period: During Japan’s inflationary period in the late 1980s, M&A transactions decreased by approximately 30% compared to the previous five-year average. This decline was driven by increased costs and economic uncertainty, which made companies more cautious about pursuing large-scale acquisitions.
2. Deflationary Period of the 2000s: In contrast, during the deflationary period of the 2000s, Japan saw a 45% increase in M&A deals, primarily driven by restructuring efforts. Companies took advantage of lower costs and the need to streamline operations, leading to a surge in M&A activity.

Current Trends and Projections

1. Inflation Rate Projections: The Bank of Japan projects inflation to remain above 2% through fiscal year 2024. This sustained inflation is expected to continue impacting M&A activities, with companies focusing on deals that offer clear cost synergies and operational efficiencies.
2. M&A Deal Value: Despite inflationary pressures, Japan’s M&A deal value increased by 23% year-on-year in 2023, reaching $123 billion. This growth was driven by acquisitions aimed at mitigating rising costs and leveraging synergies.
3. Sector-Specific Impact: Manufacturing: M&A activity in the manufacturing sector decreased by 15% in 2023 compared to 2022, as companies faced higher input costs and economic uncertainty. Technology: The technology sector saw a 25% increase in deal volume, as companies sought innovative solutions to combat rising operational costs.
4. Financing Trends: The use of all-cash deals decreased by 10% in 2023, with companies opting for more stock-based transactions to mitigate inflation risks. Private equity involvement in Japanese M&A increased by 30% in 2023, as firms sought to leverage their dry powder in an inflationary environment.

Deals

Nippon Steel’s Acquisition of U.S. Steel (2023): This $14.9 billion deal was influenced by Japan’s new Takeover Guidelines, which encourage more transparent disclosures. Nippon Steel provided detailed plans for post-acquisition synergies and cost efficiencies to justify the high price tag amidst inflationary pressures.

Hitachi’s Divestiture of Non-Core Assets (2023): Hitachi’s strategic sell-offs, totalling nearly $20 billion over five years, demonstrate a focus on streamlining operations in response to economic uncertainties. This move aligns with the Tokyo Stock Exchange’s directive for companies to improve their price-to-book ratios.

Regulatory and Market Risks

The evolving regulatory landscape and market risks associated with currency fluctuations add another layer of complexity to M&A activities. Companies must navigate these uncertainties carefully to avoid potential pitfalls. The regulatory environment in Japan, while supportive of M&A, requires companies to be diligent in their compliance efforts to ensure successful transactions. Recent regulatory changes have had direct consequences on specific deals:

1. Nidec’s acquisition of Omron’s automotive electronics business (2019-2022): This deal was initially blocked by the Japan Fair Trade Commission (JFTC) due to antitrust concerns. However, following Nidec’s commitment to divest certain overlapping businesses, the deal was approved in 2022. This case demonstrates the JFTC’s increased scrutiny of market concentration, reflecting a broader trend of stricter antitrust enforcement in Japan.
2. SoftBank’s sale of Arm to Nvidia (2020-2022): Although this deal ultimately fell through due to regulatory challenges, it exemplifies the increased scrutiny of technology-related M&A. The proposed $40 billion sale faced hurdles from multiple regulatory bodies, including Japan’s, demonstrating the global nature of regulatory risks in high-profile tech deals.

Inbound M&A

Inbound M&A deal value in Japan reached 36.2 billion dollars in 2023 a 28 percent increase from 2022 The number of inbound deals rose to 257 in 2023 up from 213 in the previous year Cross-border acquisitions accounted for 31 percent of total M&A value in Japan in 2023 up from 26 percent in 2022 Foreign direct investment stock in Japan increased by 13.2 percent year-on-year in 2023 reaching 320 billion dollars. Foreign direct investment stock in Japan increased by 13.2 percent year-on-year in 2023 reaching 320 billion dollars This rise in FDI underscores the growing confidence of foreign investors in the Japanese market and highlights the country’s attractiveness as a destination for international capital The structural changes driving this trend include Japan’s efforts to improve its business environment enhance corporate governance and foster innovation These measures have made Japanese companies more appealing to foreign investors seeking strategic opportunities in a stable and mature market.

Key Drivers

Undervalued Assets and Weak Yen: The yen’s depreciation (18% against the USD in 2023) has created a unique discount window for foreign investors. With Japanese companies trading at an average price-to-book ratio of 1.3 compared to 3.8 for S&P 500 companies, the value proposition is compelling. However, this opportunity may be time-limited as the Bank of Japan signals potential policy normalization. The current macroeconomic environment presents a rare opportunity for foreign investors to acquire high-quality Japanese assets at a significant discount. However, timing is crucial, as any shift in monetary policy could quickly close this window.

Corporate Governance Reforms: Japan’s corporate governance reforms have been transformative. The percentage of companies with independent directors comprising at least one-third of their boards increased from 58.7% in 2020 to 72.8% in 2023. This shift has led to improved capital efficiency, with the average ROE for TOPIX companies rising from 8.1% in 2020 to 9.7% in 2023. The ongoing governance reforms are creating a more shareholder-friendly environment, aligning Japanese corporate practices more closely with global standards. This trend is likely to continue, potentially leading to further unlocking of shareholder value.

Technological Expertise and Innovation: Japan’s strength in innovation is evident in its global rankings: 13th in the 2023 Global Innovation Index and third in patent applications (307,969 in 2022). Sectors like robotics, AI, and green technology are particularly strong, with Japan holding a 52% global market share in industrial robots. Japan’s technological prowess offers foreign acquirers a fast track to cutting-edge innovations. However, successfully integrating and leveraging this expertise requires a nuanced understanding of Japan’s corporate culture and innovation ecosystem.

Market Access and Brand Value: Japan’s $2.8 trillion consumer market (2023) offers significant opportunities. The country’s brands also carry global weight, with six Japanese brands in Interbrand’s top 100 global brands. Moreover, Japan’s strategic location provides a gateway to the broader Asian market, which is projected to account for 60% of global growth by 2030. Acquiring a Japanese company can provide instant access to a sophisticated consumer base and a springboard for regional expansion. However, success requires a deep understanding of local consumer preferences and business practices.

Aging Demographics and Succession Issues: With 99.7% of Japanese companies being SMEs and 60% of SME owners aged 60 or older, succession issues are creating unique acquisition opportunities. An estimated 2.45 million SME owners will reach retirement age by 2025, potentially leading to a surge in available acquisition targets. This demographic shift presents a once-in-a-generation opportunity for foreign investors to acquire well-established businesses. However, navigating the cultural sensitivities around family-owned businesses requires careful handling.

Japan’s PE opportunity

Japanese private equity is growing, helping companies reach their potential. Despite challenges like low M&A levels and family-owned businesses, the industry is progressing, highlighted by the $15 billion Toshiba buyout. Key points include increased capital, expanding talent, and a focus on shareholder value. Opportunities arise from low-interest rates and activist campaigns. Recent trends show record deal activity, especially in founder-owned companies seeking exits. Challenges remain, such as low large PE exits and a focus on subsidiary sales. To succeed, PE firms should adopt thematic investments, improve storytelling to stakeholders, and enhance value creation in companies through digital transformation and international growth. They should also invest in growth-stage companies, providing capital and accelerating development. PE can drive positive change by aligning with trends like employee engagement and modern business models.

Future Trends and Opportunities

Sector-Specific Opportunities:

Innovative deal structures are gaining importance in the Japanese M&A landscape. Foreign investors might opt for minority stake acquisitions to navigate cultural sensitivities while maintaining influence through governance rights. Joint ventures are also becoming more prevalent, combining foreign capital and expertise with Japanese market knowledge. Regional revitalization offers opportunities as the government focuses on smaller cities and rural areas, potentially providing support for acquisitions. Cross-border synergies present valuable prospects, leveraging Japan’s technological strengths and acquirers’ global distribution networks, particularly in advanced materials, precision engineering, and IoT. ESG-driven acquisitions are gaining prominence as environmental, social, and governance considerations become more critical globally, with foreign investors targeting Japanese companies with strong ESG credentials to enhance sustainability profiles and meet stakeholder expectations.

Successful Inbound M&A Transactions and Benefits:

Bain Capital’s acquisition of Showa Aircraft Industry in 2023 for $817 million is a strategic move to leverage Showa’s aerospace technology for market expansion. Bain plans to use this technology to tap into new markets, projecting a 30% increase in Showa’s revenue over the next five years through international growth.

Similarly, KKR’s acquisition of Hitachi Transport System in 2023 for $5.2 billion aims to enhance the company’s digital capabilities and expand its global logistics network. This acquisition is anticipated to boost Hitachi Transport’s operating profit margin from 5.8% to 8% within three years, reflecting KKR’s commitment to driving operational efficiency and global expansion.

Challenges for Japanese Firms

Japanese companies face several significant challenges in pursuing cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&A) in the current economic climate. These challenges stem from various factors, including increased costs, economic uncertainties, and structural issues within the Japanese business environment.

Increased Acquisition Costs: The weakened yen has significantly increased the cost of overseas acquisitions for Japanese firms. The yen’s depreciation against major currencies has made cross-border deals more expensive, potentially reducing the number of attractive targets within budget constraints. This currency effect has forced Japanese companies to be more selective in their M&A strategies and to focus on higher-value targets that can justify the increased investment.

Economic Uncertainties: Global economic uncertainties, including inflation concerns and geopolitical tensions, have made cross-border M&A more challenging. These uncertainties have led to increased caution among Japanese acquirers, with many adopting a “wait-and-see” approach. This hesitation can result in missed opportunities and slower deal execution.

Competition from Cash-Rich Global Players: Japanese firms face stiff competition from well-funded global players, including private equity firms with substantial dry powder. This competition often drives up acquisition prices, making it harder for Japanese companies to secure attractive deals within their risk parameters.

Future Outlook

The outlook for Japanese cross-border M&A is cautiously optimistic. As Japan’s economy stabilizes, companies are expected to continue pursuing international expansion through strategic acquisitions, driven by the need to seek growth opportunities beyond their mature domestic market. With an aging population and slow economic growth, Japanese firms will look abroad to access new markets and revenue streams. The technology sector, particularly in areas like AI, robotics, and advanced manufacturing, will remain a key focus as companies seek to enhance their digital capabilities. Economic stabilization in Japan and globally could provide a more favorable environment for M&A, although geopolitical tensions and trade disputes may introduce complexities. The weakened yen will continue to play a dual role, making Japanese assets more attractive to foreign buyers while increasing the cost of overseas acquisitions for Japanese firms, impacting the balance between inbound and outbound M&A activity.

Despite positive indicators, challenges remain. Japanese firms need to improve post-merger integration, especially in managing cross-cultural issues and retaining key talent. To address these challenges, they should invest in cross-cultural training, develop strategic integration plans with clear roadmaps, and establish governance structures with realistic timelines. Talent retention strategies should include tailored packages, mentorship programs, and clear career paths. Firms should foster innovation through best practice exchanges, cross-functional teams, and reverse mentoring. Enhancing communication with a clear acquisition narrative and change management training is essential. Lastly, they should establish long-term performance metrics beyond financial results, such as cultural integration and employee satisfaction, and regularly assess and adjust strategies.

---

Read more about our strategy & advisory expertise

---

References:

• Goldman Sachs, “Japan M&A Outlook 2024,” https://www.goldmansachs.com/what-we-do/investment-banking/insights/articles/ma-outlook-2024/report.pdf
• JP Morgan, “M&A Activity in 2024,” https://www.jpmorgan.com/investment-banking/mergers-and-acquisitions-market-outlook
• EY, “Global Capital Confidence Barometer,” https://www.ey.com/en_gl/ccb
• McKinsey & Company, “The challenge of cross-border M&A for Japanese companies,” https://www.mckinsey.com/business-functions/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/the-challenge-of-cross-border-m-and-a-for-japanese-companies
• McKinsey & Company, “A force for good, Japan’s private equity opportunity,” https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/private-capital/our-insights/a-force-for-good-japans-private-equity-opportunity
• Bain, “M&A in Japan: Resilient Activity—but Now It’s Time for More,” https://www.bain.com/insights/japan-m-and-a-report-2024/
• UBS, “Global M&A Outlook,” https://www.ubs.com/global/en/investment-bank/in-focus/2023/m-and-a-activity-set-to-recover-in-2024.html